Skip to main content

GDP and Development

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is a good measure of country’s growth. Does it inform the disparity in society and access to goods or services for poor at the bottom of the economic pyramid? Despite high economic growth number of poor continues to grow worldwide and natural resources deteriorate at faster rate. We need to understand the current model of economic development and how much loss of natural resources occur per unit of so called GDP growth and also how much impact on people whose life is displaced in the name of economic development. There is increasing social unrest in many parts of the world against big development plans. If these development programs are intended to improve the lives of people then why some people are protesting? We need to understand this from social and ecological point of view. As I am writing this, I came across news from India (http://www.indianexpress.com/news/kids-join-posco-stir-no-point-studying-if-our-land-is-gone/1071116/). Kids join Posco stir: ‘No point studying if our land is gone’- A steel plant is a way of economic development in remote area in the state of Orissa for this project. Land acquisition is the bone of contention between villagers and Posco -a South Korean conglomerate. Villagers are real people and their land and other natural resources belong to them as they have been taking care of it for ages. Now if a big corporate takes their land away, the only source of livelihood for majority of them, and build a steel plant that will employ engineers from cities, what would be impact on social and natural capital, the well-being of people displaced by this project. How many people from this village will get jobs in this project, bear in mind majority are unskilled, uneducated and remained out of the development process in the last 70 years since India gained independence. I am sure Posco must have done Feasibility studies and consultations with representatives in the region (politicians and local leaders) before starting this project and obtained environmental clearances etc. however, why people are protesting and even joined by kids as mentioned in this news. Obviously, it impacts on the livelihood generating activities, way of living in new development scenario, displacement, they might end up working in cities as labourers as compared to owner of the land and working with self-esteem. Another issue that these communities have to face might be -increased alcoholism and drug use when they get some compensation in cash. This will have serious consequences for women of the household as they usually manage household in rural areas, looking after children, family and farm. Now if land is gone, men folk might take to alcohol as the cash ends up in the hands of men folks as they are legal owners of the land. Women often find themselves in dire conditions after such displacements and so called compensations in the name of economic development in rural and remote areas. We need to understand these social, ecological and economic complexities that a simple development project can set up in remote areas. Unfortunately, people and nature has to bear those impacts with heavy price on society with severe consequences in other parts of the country or society. Are we ready to pay the price?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Campaign for the Support of Farmers in India

INDIAN GOVERNMENT NEEDS TO LISTEN TO FARMERS IN REFORMING AGRICULTURE IN INDIA   1. Three new  farm acts  in India are proving to be the last straw for about 90 million small-holders and their families. This has grave implications for about 800 million rural dwellers who are directly or indirectly dependent on farming for their livelihood. In addition, food security of the entire nation with 1.35 billion population is at risk. 2. Indian government maintains that these farm laws will usher a new economic revolution in the ailing farm sector. 3. Whereas farmers are opposing as they fear losing their land – only source of their livelihood – to corporate backed agri-enterprises. 4. The protest and persistence by farmers have opened up an opportunity for a dialogue between farmers and the government and for a new beginning. This has potential to reform small-holder agriculture but in close consultation with the farmers. 5. However, the rights of these farmers and many associat...

Local Food Systems for Sustainability

Local, traditional, and indigenous food systems were successful in supplying year-round requirements for food and within the environmental constraints.  How were they able to do it? What were the practices and principles of local food systems that helped them thrive and maintain growing population in many parts of the world?  These food systems have been embedded in the society. Many traditional societies evolved around such unique food systems. Such food systems have been maintaining agricultural biodiversity and are important source of knowledge and culture as documented by the  Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems  (GIAHS) of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation. For example,  rice-fish-duck system in China,   traditional agriculture of Koraput, India ,  Noto’s Satoyama and Satoumi in Japan ,  Andean agriculture, Peru ,  Maasai Pastoralist Heritage Area in Tanzania , etc. These have been well doc...

Future of Small Farms: A Bridge Between Society and the Environment

Small farmers can feed the world, help protect the environment and also provide livelihoods to millions of families who manage them. In addition, they produce valuable farm commodities for market and add value local and global economy. Future of agriculture is in protecting, supporting and improving small farms and the families who manage them.  There are about 500 million small farms that provide direct and indirect employment to about 2 billion people. Small farms also generate valuable social capital by creating numerous opportunities for local community. They provide fresh produce to local shops, butchers, abattoirs, and support many cafes and restaurants that offer local cuisine, which is not possible without local and fresh produce. Local community depends on the viability of small farm and farming community, which are also source of employment for local population.  They act as a fabric spread over the landscape and enhance both social and natural capi...